We ended up getting an oversized cupcake from Kroger for Madelyn's smash cake. I could have made one but since we weren't serving cake I didn't want to deal with all the leftover cake batter. Plus, I figure I've got plenty of birthday cakes ahead of me.
At first, she was a little apprehensive because she didn't like the frosting on her hands. Then my genius baby discovered that by picking up the cake and shoving it into her face she wouldn't get frosting on her hands.